and before I knew it my hip-hop confession had come tumbling out of me: I didn’t get it, I needed melody, I was too distracted by liberal guilt to enjoy the parts of it I did like. This was a more acceptable thing to say back then, but it was still extremely uncool. And I went all the way: all those white boys in my high school dressing in FUBU, I said, calling their cheerleader girlfriends “bitches,” then going home to McMansions bought with inherited wealth from social programs that excluded Black people—it made me cringe, I said.