Jack is watching me. I stare right back at him. I am not afraid of pirates.
“You’ll give us our stuff back,” I say. “You don’t look dishonorable.”
In fact they do, but flattery might be our best bet in this situation.
“Ha!” Cole grins. “Sure we do. We’re Baileys. Didn’t your grandparents warn you about us?”
“Actually, they did,” says Gretchen.
“Yeah? And what did they say?”
I don’t want Gretchen to make things worse, so I interrupt. “Did you know there are gravestones under that tree in the back?”
“Yeah,” says Jack. “Why do you care?”
“Whose are they?”
He shrugs. “Don’t know.”
“Well, didn’t you ever try to look?”
“Nah. Don’t care.”
“Can I clean them off?”
Gretchen tugs on my sleeve. “Fin, let’s just go.”
“Why do you care about them?” Jack asks me.
“Because it’s disrespectful to leave them dirty,” I say. “People are supposed to take care of the dead.”
No one says anything. Jack pulls a piece of paper out of his pocket—my list of favorite words—and carefully smooths out the wrinkles.
“Is this yours?” he asks me.
I could snatch it away from him and run, but I stay put. “Yes.”
He reads over the list. “Sinister. Footfall. There are a lot of words here.”
“I’ve worked hard on them. I love words.”
Jack scratches the back of his head, messing up his hair. He disappears and comes back with our box.
“Jack!” hisses Cole. “What are you doing, man? Come on.”
“You can have this back,” says Jack, “but only if you clean up the gravestones.”
I think about that. “We can’t do it today. We have to get home.”
“Then when you come back to clean, you can have your stuff.”
Gretchen looks ready to bite him. “Why can’t you clean them off?”
Jack grins. “Because Cole’s scared of ghosts and doesn’t want to ‘curse our family.’ ”
“Shut up, Jack!” Cole pushes him, his face turning red. “I just hate cleaning. It’s pointless.”
I hold out my hand. “It’s a deal.”